Skip to main content

Advocacy

Now I know what my life is worth...
Author Last Post
“… finding those rural, low traffic volume roads is well worth it. “

This is a great point. Is there a way that we can identify these for the whole group?


Absolutely not. We should not be forcing ourselves off the road because of bad motor vehicle drivers. Riders need to start using dashcams on all their rides. GoPro, Cycliq, Garmin, 360, there are plenty of options. Hold drivers accountable.


Who can keep up with the case and post here when hearings are coming up? The cycling community need to be writing letters and showing up. There should be no reason why the courts cannot remove this guy's commercial vehicle license for life.

Unwarranted animosity is not just limited towards cyclists in our "rage" society but cyclists are easily the most vulnerable targets on the road. There is little to no respect for anyone, let alone cyclists, that riles irrational people, whether on or off the road. Throw into the mix drunk, high, distracted, impatient, and angry drivers...well most of us understand that. Gravel cycling has exploded in popularity for good reason.


Beyond hi-viz kits and exceedingly bright lights, finding those rural, low traffic volume roads is well worth it. Saying goodbye to favorite roads or routes due to changing traffic dynamics should be an obvious choice. Yeah, we have the "right" to ride on almost any road but not all roads are created equal, they change from being safely rideable to absolutely not worth it.


Animosity? Case in point;


https://wlos.com/news/local/fletcher-police-seek-public-help-identifying-pickup-driver-threatened-cyclist-bicyclist-livingston-farms-community-north-sunberry-trail-running-briar#




While it's true that is what WLOS reported, the source was the driver of the truck. Hardly a bastion of credibility, I'd say.


My POV is that unfortunately, it is unlikely the driver will receive much if any punishment for striking 3 cyclists and killing two. It's his words that will be the only ones that count. No witnesses.


As cyclists, I'm afraid we're left with trying to be alert at all times, avoiding roads with heavy, speeding traffic with no shoulders, being visible, and advocating for changes to law enforcement, infrastructure, and motorist education. For reasons that baffle me, there is a lot of animosity against cyclists; it's like we're little more than vermin. Sad to say.

Asheville Citizen time provided more info than WLOS. It seems the driver heard a pop and went left of center. Was driving at 45mph in a 55 zone.


Club rules require lights or reflectors in accordance with NC law. NC law only require reflectors or lights in low lighting conditions. With that said, bright clothing really isn't the answer. I have found in the last 4 years of commuting to work it's all about lights. As high as possible and as bright as possible.

Neither bright clothing or lights would have prevented the driver of the truck from crossing the center line of the road and hitting the three cyclists, killing two. NC law requires front and rear lights "on the Blue Ridge Parkway"; not in other places given appropriate daylight (although I have used F and R lights during daylight hours for years, and I'm a strong advocate for both.)

Thank you for sharing your perspectives on this. Another senseless tragedy that probably could’ve been avoided. The investigation will ultimately reveal what the cause was, certainly not worth speculating over on this thread.


At this point, it makes me wonder what can we all do to be more proactively “defensive” in future rides.. wearing bright clothing and using riding lights are smart. Obviously the accident we are discussing involves something that clothes & lights wouldn’t prevent.


BRBC road rides mention North Carolina law requires such lights. I’ve been on some group road rides where I notice people lack rear lights and/or front lights. Are we at the point where we need to police ourselves and tell people who lack riding lights that you can’t ride?


I understand that good riding lights & camera lights are expensive. Is there anyway we can possibly do a group purchase to get a reduced price from one of our sponsors?




Thank you Zachary for your insight, much appreciated.



To keep tabs on the criminal case, use the new ePortal, and input Mundy, Cody: https://portal-nc.tylertech.cloud/Portal/Home/Dashboard/29.


Because it's a Madison County case, you won't be able to access anything about it online until MadCo is transitioned into the ePortal system, which is happening this coming Monday (July 21). Once the ePortal system is up and running for MadCo, you can input the case number here to receive notifications of court dates: https://www3.nccourts.org/onlineservices/notifications/menu.sp


A quick look at what's available on there about the defendant already shows that he's in debt more than $7,000 for a 2015 judgment against him to the tune of $4,000 which he's failed to make any payments on; and that he was evicted in 2019 from the home he and his family lived in, and then moved just around the corner into a mobile home. But no prior criminal record - the lone traffic ticket for not wearing his seatbelt is just an infraction - so he is unlikely to serve any time in jail at all.


To the extent that money damages can provide any recompense for this wretched loss of life, the families will be able to obtain insurance payouts and can file civil suit and would likely get a judgment against the defendant and perhaps the owner of the truck. But depending on what assets are available to satisfy those judgments, their legal fees could very likely outweigh any return they'd receive - the defendant certainly doesn't have any funds, and the owner is reportedly a younger individual without very deep reserves.


In my experience, satisfying outcomes are not available through the court system - it's just the stopgap when all else fails. When a defendant goes to jail, with rare exception, their incarceration doesn't improve the experience of the victims or of the convicted. Our penal system doesn't focus on rehabilitation and so the person who goes in is the same who comes out, but usually worse for wear. And that person is then once again back in society, returned to whatever circumstances and choices led them to their antisocial conduct to begin with.


That said, there should be more serious penalties for taking the life of a cyclist, in the hopes that it would serve as deterrence, both generally to all motorists and to a specific defendant. For that to change, we'd have to advocate with legislators and build a groundswell of people large enough to overcome the inertia of the status quo. Anyone who's paying attention to our legislature knows that's an effort with very long odds. And then we'd have to prevail on District Attorney's to prosecute those more serious charges.


Perhaps more achievable are efforts being spearheaded by Adam, the owner of On Your Bike in Marshall, of being in the ear of all the stakeholders who have sway over improving the safety of that road, of installing rumble strips in the center lane, of reducing the max speed, of perhaps changing access to the landfill and securing funding for more protected bike lanes: https://www.instagram.com/p/DL-zC_9hVcA/


I write this as someone who is an attorney, previously a public defender outside of NC, and am still in the middle of litigating and dealing with the fallout from a drunk driver plowing into my family in Pennsylvania over a year ago and grievously injuring my elderly parents. I'm also a regular cyclist in MadCo, though I usually ride alone and in the more rural parts of the county. My heart goes out to the cyclist's families for their loss and the added heartbreak of witnessing how ineffective the law is to respond to this crime.


Lastly, this outfit usually has the most detailed and accurate summation of the law in this area: https://www.bikelaw.com/2024/01/bikes-criminal-justice/ and this recounting of what appears to be the first instance of punitive damages for distracted driving that resulted in a cyclist death in NC provides significant insight into that process: https://www.bikelaw.com/2019/01/death-by-distracted-driving/

Good to know. Max penalty for "misdemeanor death by vehicle" is 150 days in jail. So, if found guilty and sentenced to the maximum, served consecutively (all highly doubtful), the driver will get less than a year in jail. Meanwhile, the two cyclists will still be... well, dead.


But according to the cop, the driver of the dump truck is very sad, so it's all good, right?


Meanwhile, "Buncombe County Commissioners awarded a $2 million contract to expand the county landfill in Alexander by 4.7 acres. Construction is slated to begin in August and last about seven months — the expanded area is expected to be used for five to six years before reaching capacity." So more trucks.

Link below to the Asheville Citizen Times article that contains more details of the "accident." Unless the toxicology report and/or the dump truck inspection reveals something incriminating, the perp will probably accept a plea deal in lieu of a trial.


https://www.citizen-times.com/story/news/crime/2025/07/16/north-carolina-driver-charged-in-crash-that-killed-asheville-cyclists/85250091007/


We cyclists have the legal right to ride on the road, but does that necessarily mean it is safe to ride on each and every road?

The laws of physics says otherwise, ride smart and ride safe.





https://wlos.com/news/local/dump-truck-driver-charged-in-crash-that-killed-two-cyclists-in-madison-county


What now? Who in the club has the ability to follow this case? Who can send out updates of when court hearings are going to be? Who knows how the system works and can keep the rest of us informed? Charges against this driver have given ever other motor vehicle driver a licence to kill

Return to Forum